The fit question comes before the price
The Dome Cover and Arc XL Cover look like similar weather covers in the Gozney range, but they are built for different ovens. The single most useful check is model compatibility: the Dome Cover is compatible with both Dome and Dome S1, while the Arc XL Cover is designed to fit perfectly over the Arc XL. Neither cover is a universal fit, so choosing by price alone risks buying a cover that will not sit correctly on your oven.
This comparison focuses on what the supplied product information confirms: which ovens each cover is made for, how each one is secured, and what weather protection both share. Where a detail is not confirmed, treat it as a decision limitation rather than assuming a feature.
Compatibility and fit details side by side
- Dome Cover compatibility: Compatible with both Dome and Dome S1. It is explicitly not compatible with Dome (Gen 2) or Dome XL (Gen 2), so owners of those newer models should not choose this cover.
- Arc XL Cover compatibility: Designed to fit perfectly over the Arc XL. The supplied information does not list other compatible ovens, so treat it as an Arc XL-specific cover rather than a multi-model option.
- Dome Cover fitting details: Designed to fit over your oven on a counter-top or when using the stand, with or without the door and Neapolitan arch in use. Heavy-duty zips with pleats assist fitting, and a pull tag tightens the fit around the base.
- Arc XL Cover fitting details: Strong and simple toggle retention straps are supplied to secure the cover, and a pull tag tightens the fit around the base of the oven.
Dome Cover evidence for the fit decision
- Dome Cover: Compatible with both Dome and Dome S1; not compatible with Dome (Gen 2) or Dome XL (Gen 2). This is the deciding fact for older Dome and Dome S1 owners, and the reason newer Dome owners should stop here.

Dome Cover - Dome Cover: Designed to fit over the oven on a counter-top or when using the stand, with or without the door and Neapolitan arch in use. Useful if you leave the door or arch in place and want a cover that accounts for those accessories.
- Dome Cover: Material: 350gr/m2 100% Polyester, PVC coated, with heavy-duty zips and pleats to assist fitting. Explains how the cover is built and why the zip-and-pleat design matters when fitting it around the oven.
Weather protection: what both covers share
Both covers use water repellent material and are described as UV stable. Gozney states that each gives protection from rain, wind, frost, UV, salt, insects and wildlife, and that each helps prevent anything from getting into the oven that could inhibit overall performance.
That shared protection means weather resistance is not the deciding difference between these two covers. The real difference is which oven each one fits and how it is secured. If your oven is a Dome or Dome S1, the Dome Cover is the matching option; if it is an Arc XL, the Arc XL Cover is the matching option.
Arc XL Cover evidence for the fit decision
- Arc XL Cover: Designed to fit perfectly over the Arc XL oven. Confirms the intended oven, so Arc XL owners can choose with confidence rather than adapting a cover made for another model.

Arc XL Cover - Arc XL Cover: Strong and simple toggle retention straps secure the cover, with a pull tag to tighten the fit around the base. Retention matters in exposed outdoor kitchens where wind can lift a loose cover.
- Arc XL Cover: Material: 350gr/m2 100% Polyester, PVC coated, water repellent and UV stable. Shows the Arc XL Cover uses the same material specification as the Dome Cover, so the choice comes down to fit, not fabric.
Choose by oven, not by cover
Use this short decision path before ordering:
- You own a Dome or Dome S1: Choose the Dome Cover. It is the cover explicitly listed as compatible with both models.
- You own a Dome (Gen 2) or Dome XL (Gen 2): Do not choose the Dome Cover. The supplied compatibility note states it is not compatible with either model, so look for a cover made for your oven instead.
- You own an Arc XL: Choose the Arc XL Cover, which is designed to fit that oven and includes toggle retention straps.
- You want one cover for several ovens: The supplied information does not confirm a single cover that fits both the Dome family and the Arc XL, so plan per oven rather than assuming one cover covers all.
What the supplied information does not confirm
The supplied records do not include dimensions, weight, or a stated operating temperature for either cover, so this comparison cannot confirm clearance figures or heat-related limits. They also do not list care instructions beyond the material and water repellent description. If you need those specifics, check the full product documentation before buying rather than relying on assumptions.
What the records do confirm is enough for the main decision: the Dome Cover is for Dome and Dome S1, and the Arc XL Cover is for the Arc XL. Match the cover to the oven you actually own, and the fit question answers itself.


